The Woman & the Dragon

The evidence · a mark to watch

They Will Seek Death and Not Find It

Transhumanism promises a life without death, made by human hands. I watch it beside two texts: the people who "will seek death but will not find it" (Revelation 9:6), and the second beast, who gives breath to a made thing (Revelation 13:15).

Home › The Evidence › They Will Seek Death and Not Find It

✓ Reviewed by Fr. John How this site is made

Where this page standsThis is Fr. John's reading, not the Church's teaching, and it is the lightest mark on this site: something to watch, graded possible and no more. No Father reads Revelation 9:6 this way, and the technology it supposes does not exist. Words and deeds are weighed here, never souls (CCC 1861). Medicine that heals and lengthens life is a good, and nothing on this page is said against it or against anyone who hopes in it.

What transhumanism is

By transhumanism I mean the hope of overcoming the limits of human nature, and death above all, by technique: medicine, machines and the remaking of the body, so that earthly life could be prolonged without end. It is a current of thought with many voices and no single author. Caring for one's health, and medicine that cures and lengthens life, are not transhumanism; the Church calls life and health precious gifts to be cared for reasonably (CCC 2288). What I watch is the promise that death itself can be abolished by human power.

The texts

Revelation 9. At the fifth trumpet the shaft of the abyss is opened and locusts come out of its smoke. They may harm only those who do not have the seal of God on their foreheads, and they may not kill them, only torment them for five months (Revelation 9:1–5). Then: these people "will seek death but will not find it"; they long to die, and death escapes them (Revelation 9:6).

Revelation 13. The second beast has an image made for the first beast and is permitted "to breathe life" into it, so that it speaks (Revelation 13:14–15). He serves a beast whose mortal wound was healed, a mimicry of the Lord's death and Resurrection (Revelation 13:3, 12).

My reading

I ask whether a deathless life made by human hands could become the life Revelation 9:6 describes: a life one cannot leave. And I watch it beside the second beast, because his work in Revelation 13 is to give a counterfeit of life, breath to a made thing, in the service of a beast whose healing counterfeits the Resurrection. A promise of life without death, and without God, would be that same counterfeit offered to everyone. The true promise is different in kind: "whoever believes in me, even if he dies, will live" (John 11:25). Christ does not abolish death by technique. He passes through it and opens it.

I grade this mark possible. It is a watch, not a claim that anything is fulfilled.

What the Church teaches

How the Church's writers have read Revelation 9:6

None of the early commentators reads the verse of a technology or of a life prolonged by human skill.

Source: Revelation, ed. William C. Weinrich, Ancient Christian Commentary on Scripture, New Testament XII (InterVarsity Press, 2005), on 9:6; summarized on The Lamb's Victory, chapter 9.

What has been seen

The case against

Against the reading of Revelation 9:6.

Against tying it to the second beast.

Would strengthen: a promise of life without death preached as a salvation, above all if joined to allegiance to a ruler; the second beast's hand in such a project, by his money, his companies or his word. Would weaken: the remark standing alone, with nothing after it; the hope of abolishing death fading as its promises fail. Standing: not yet seen.

What is asked of us

Not fear. The Pope's own answer to this hope is not alarm but Easter: death is not the opposite of life, and Christ has made it a passage. We are asked to prepare for a good death, to care for the sick and the dying, and to hope for the resurrection that only God can give. See Hope and Stand Firm.

Continue